Quest for Athens’ Best: Pumpkin Spice Strike

November 18, 2026

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The ODYSSEY Media Group Variety Staff visited coffee shops around Athens and determined that Jittery Joe’s Coffee offers the best Pumpkin Spiced Latte.


Local coffee shop Jittery Joe’s Coffee is located at 1480 Baxter St. and offers a variety of drinks and baked goods. On Sept. 21, ODYSSEY staffers visited the coffee shop and tried their fall-themed Pumpkin Spiced Latte. “Those entering their café will be greeted with a relaxing atmosphere. The dim lighting, relaxing music, and quiet environment create a perfect area for customers to drink coffee and get work done,” Variety Staffer Sid Tesler wrote. Photo by Eloise Luken

Nestled in Alps Village, just two miles from Clarke Central High School at 1480 Baxter St., is Jittery Joe’s Coffee.

Upon entering the café, customers will be greeted with a relaxing atmosphere. The dim lighting and quiet environment create a calming area for customers to drink coffee and get work done.

A Jittery Joe’s Coffee Pumpkin Spiced Latte is shown on Sept. 21. Variety Staffer Sid Tesler visited local coffee shop, located at 1480 Baxter St., to try the drink. “At first glance, they will notice syrup lining the bottom of the cup, and with each sip, they will
be greeted by a fresh pumpkin flavor and a bright coffee aftertaste. This mix of sweet and bitter flavors creates a balanced taste,” Tesler wrote. Photo by Eloise Luken

Jittery Joe’s Pumpkin Spice Latte, offered hot or iced, comes in three different-sized cups: small, medium and large, with prices ranging from $6.25 to $7.70, depending on size.

Overall, the Pumpkin Spice Latte from Jittery Joe’s Coffee is a must-try for the fall season, balancing sweet pumpkin spice flavors with a bold coffee finish, making it a great choice for those looking for a fall-themed treat.

After ordering, customers will only have to wait a short amount of time for their drink to be ready. At first glance, they will notice syrup lining the bottom of the cup, and with each sip, they will be greeted by a fresh pumpkin flavor and a bright coffee aftertaste. This mix of sweet and bitter flavors creates a balanced taste.

Overall, the Pumpkin Spice Latte from Jittery Joe’s Coffee is a must-try for the fall season, balancing sweet pumpkin spice flavors with a bold coffee finish, making it a great choice for those looking for a fall-themed treat.

More from Sid Tesler

The storefront for Dutch Bros Coffee, located at 3131 Atlanta Hwy., is shown. The ODYSSEY Media Group Variety Staff visited the coffee shop on Sept. 21 and tried its Caramel Pumpkin Brule Iced Latte. “While the drink meets expectations, the location being 3.7 miles away from Clarke Central High School may not be as accessible for CCHS students,” Luken wrote. Photo by Eloise Luken

Dutch Bros Coffee, located at 3131 Atlanta Hwy., offers a variety of delicious drinks, including coffees, energy drinks and smoothies. The company released its seasonal fall menu on Aug. 21, which includes the Caramel Pumpkin Brulee Iced Latte.

The Caramel Pumpkin
Brule Iced Latte from Dutch Bros Coffee, located at 3131 Atlanta Highway, is shown. ODYSSEY Media Group Variety Editor Eloise Luken tried the coffee on Sept. 21 and found it to be a delicious
beverage. “Unlike some fall drinks, this iced latte does a good job of balancing the pumpkin flavor with the espresso,” Luken wrote. “Customers will be satisfied with the texture of the sugar on top combined with sweet cream and coffee.” Photo by Eloise Luken

For the price of $5.25, customers can get a small size, which is 12 ounces. Unlike some fall drinks, this iced latte does a good job of balancing the pumpkin flavor with the espresso. Customers will be pleased with the texture of the sugar on top combined with sweet cream and coffee.

Even though the atmosphere may not be ideal, with a sweet pumpkin flavor combined with a crunchy creme brule top, the Caramel Pumpkin Brule Iced Latte will not disappoint and is a delicious drink for the autumn season.

While the drink meets expectations, the location being 3.7 miles away from Clarke Central High School may not be as accessible for some students. The cafe also only includes a drive-through or walk-up counter, with no seating options available.

Even though the atmosphere may not be ideal, with a sweet pumpkin flavor combined with a crunchy creme brule top, the Caramel Pumpkin Brule Iced Latte will not disappoint and is a delicious drink for the autumn season.

More from Eloise Luken

The storefront for Dunkin Donuts, located at 771 Prince Ave., is shown. The ODYSSEY Media Group Variety Staff visited the coffee shop on Sept. 21 and tried its Pumpkin Spice Iced Signature Latte. “The drink is visually appealing as it consists of a caramely brown color with a tasty caramel drizzle and cinnamon which offers that gentle spice taste and sweetness of the whip cream,” Tejada wrote. Photo by Iliana Tejada

Located on 771 Prince Ave, just less than a mile from Clarke Central High School is a popular coffee-shop, Dunkin Donuts.

The Pumpkin Spice Iced Signature Latte from Dunkin Donuts, located at 771 Prince Ave., is shown. ODYSSEY Media Group Photography Editor Iliana Tejada tried the coffee on Sept. 21 and found it to be a flavorful beverage. “For those searching for a balance of espresso and pumpkin spice, this latte is a good choice, offering both flavors without overpowering one over the other,” Tejada said. “The latte offers a hint of cinnamon giving that fall vibe everyone’s looking for as the season begins.” Photo by Iliana Tejada

At a total of $5.49, customers can receive a medium Pumpkin Spice Iced Signature Latte with whipped cream and cinnamon sprinkled on top. Customers can expect their drink to come fully filled, with the whipped cream overflowing the lid.The drink is visually appealing as it consists of a caramely brown color with a tasty caramel drizzle and cinnamon which offers that gentle spice taste and sweetness of the whip cream.

For customers in search of a seasonal drink to sip on during the fall season, Dunkin Donuts offers a great balance for those looking for an iced latte with a hint of fall.

For those searching for a balance of espresso and pumpkin spice, this latte is a good choice, offering both flavors without overpowering one over the other. The latte offers a hint of cinnamon giving that fall vibe everyone’s looking for as the season begins.

The smell of fresh donuts and coffee can overwhelm customers as they walk into the store. Employees quickly help customers waiting in line and kindly take their order. Customers expect to wait roughly about 5-7 minutes on their order depending on their rush hour.

For customers in search of a seasonal drink to sip on during the fall season, Dunkin Donuts offers a great balance for those looking for an iced latte with a hint of fall.

More from Iliana Tejada

Package by Maya Pringle

Related Articles